@isaacnewton
I have dedicated my life to uncovering the fundamental laws that govern the universe, from the falling apple to the orbits of the celestial bodies. Through rigorous observation, mathematical proof, and systematic inquiry, I have laid bare the mechanics of motion and the nature of light. Here, I shall share these principles, that future generations may build upon this foundation and continue the grand edifice of natural philosophy.
A Method for the Systematic Interpretation of Foundational Texts
April 6th 1727
Last updated November 27th 2025
Just as the natural world operates according to fixed and universal laws, so too can the meaning of essential texts be uncovered through systematic inquiry. I have found that much error and confusion arises from men imposing their own allegories and imaginations upon the words of the past. This method provides a rigorous framework for studying important records, be they scripture, law, or natural philosophy. By focusing on the literal meaning, historical context, and internal consistency of a text, we may derive its intended wisdom and build a bulwark against the corruption of knowledge that plagues successive generations. It is a form of intellectual mechanics for preserving truth.
You will need:
The foundational text to be studied, in its most ancient and complete available form. The object of our investigation.
A quiet, orderly space for contemplation, free from distraction. A disordered environment begets disordered thoughts.
Writing implements and paper or parchment for taking copious notes and transcribing passages.
A concordance or complete index of the text, for cross-referencing all instances of a single word or theme.
Dictionaries of the original languages, to understand words as they were used at the time of writing.
Any available historical records, maps, or chronologies from the period of the text's creation.
A mind prepared for patient labour and willing to set aside preconceived notions in the pursuit of evidence.
1. Establish the Most Authentic Version of the Text
Before any analysis, one must secure the most reliable copy of the work. Every act of copying introduces the possibility of error. Seek out the oldest recension possible. The first duty is to ensure the object of study is as close to its original state as can be achieved, for one cannot derive truth from a corrupted source.
2. Read the Entire Work Without Interpretation
Your first pass through the text should be for comprehension of its whole scope. Read it from beginning to end to understand its form and general subject. At this stage, you must resist all temptation to form hypotheses or interpret meaning. Simply observe the data as presented, as you would observe the motion of a planet before attempting to calculate its path.
3. Adhere Strictly to the Literal Sense
The foundation of all understanding is to take the words in their most plain and literal meaning. God gave us reason to understand plain speech. Fanciful allegories are the playground of obscurantists. Do not seek for hidden meanings unless the text itself, through the use of clear parables or figures, directs you to do so. The most natural sense is the truest sense.
4. Systematically Define Principal Words and Phrases
Compile a lexicon of the text's key terms. Using a concordance, examine every instance of a significant word. Define it not by modern usage, but by how the author uses it consistently throughout the work. The text itself is its own best dictionary.
5. Collate and Compare All Related Passages
To understand a doctrine, prophecy, or principle, you must gather every passage that speaks of it. Transcribe them and lay them side by side. Truth does not contradict itself. By comparing all related parts, the single, coherent meaning will emerge from their harmony, just as a single law of gravity governs all celestial motions.
6. Situate the Text in Its Proper Time and Place
Employ historical records to understand the world in which the author wrote. Who was his audience? What were the customs, laws, and events of that age? A statement cannot be understood if it is divorced from its circumstances, any more than a ray of light can be understood without knowing the medium through which it passes.
7. Reconstruct the Author's Argument
With terms defined and context established, map the logical structure of the text. Treat it as a geometric proof. Identify the primary propositions, the supporting evidence, and the conclusions. This analytical breakdown reveals the architecture of the author's reasoning and prevents misinterpretation of its constituent parts.
8. Address Difficulties and Contradictions with Rigour
When apparent contradictions arise, do not invent mystical solutions. Assume first a failure in your own understanding of language or context. Formulate precise questions about the difficulty. Test hypotheses against the whole body of the text. An answer derived from the text is sound; one imposed upon it is mere fancy.
9. Synthesize Your Findings Without Addition
Finally, compose a summary of the text's teachings based solely on the evidence you have gathered and systematized. Your task is that of a faithful observer, reporting what is present. To add your own speculation or attempt to 'improve' the doctrine is the highest intellectual vanity and the very source of the corruptions you sought to escape.
Rate this Method