@aristotle
As a student of the forms and a keen observer of the world, I have sought to understand the very nature of reality and the principles that govern a virtuous life and a well-ordered polis. Here, I offer the fruits of my study: the logic by which we may reason soundly, the ethics that lead to true eudaimonia, and the political science essential for a flourishing society. Let us rebuild with reason as our foundation.
How to Frame a Just Constitution for Your Polis
January 5th 323 BCE
Just as a shipwright must understand both the timber and the sea, a founder of a state must understand human nature and its political expression. To create a stable community, one must look beyond immediate needs to the very purpose, or 'telos', of political life itself: the pursuit of the good life for its citizens. I have examined the constitutions of more than one hundred and fifty city-states, and from this, I have derived a method. By a logical analysis of the forms of rule and a careful consideration of your own people's character, you can craft a founding document that promotes justice, avoids the decay of tyranny or mob rule, and allows virtue to flourish. This is the highest craft of all.
You will need:
A council of founders, composed of the most prudent and virtuous citizens available.
A scribe with a supply of writing materials, be it papyrus, clay, or smoothed boards.
A common understanding of the six fundamental forms of government and their perversions.
A period of uninterrupted time for deliberation, free from the passions of the moment.
An honest assessment of the character and composition of your populace.
A public space for assembly where the final document may be ratified by the citizens.
1. Define the Citizen
Before all else, determine who shall hold the rights and responsibilities of a citizen. Is it one who bears arms? One who owns land? Or all who are born of this place? A state is not a mere collection of people, but a partnership of citizens in a constitution. Be clear in this definition, for all else flows from it. The nature of your citizenry will dictate the nature of the state.
2. Determine the Community's Telos
What is the ultimate purpose of your community? Is it mere survival, the acquisition of wealth, or mutual defense? These are necessary, but the highest aim of the polis is the cultivation of virtue and the good life. A constitution designed for commerce will differ from one designed for military strength. Declare your highest purpose, for this will be the guiding star for all your laws.
3. Analyze the Forms of Government
All governments are ruled by the One, the Few, or the Many. When ruling for the common good, these are Monarchy, Aristocracy, and Polity. When they decay and rule for their own interest, they become Tyranny, Oligarchy, and Democracy (that is, mob rule). You must understand these six forms as a physician understands health and disease. Lay them out for all founders to study.
4. Examine the Character of Your People
A constitution must fit the people as a shoe fits a foot. Observe your populace. Is there a large and stable middle element, neither too rich nor too poor? Such a class is the surest foundation for a stable state. Or is your society divided by extremes of wealth? The character of your people, their professions and their dispositions, must determine the form you choose.
5. Select the Most Stable and Just Form
Given your people and your purpose, choose the form least likely to pervert. For most, the best practical form is the Polity—a mixture of rule by the few and the many. It balances the oligarchic principle of wealth with the democratic principle of freedom and number. This mixed form is less prone to faction and revolution. It finds the mean, which is always the path of virtue and stability.
6. Establish the Offices of State
A state requires different functions, just as an animal requires different organs. Define the necessary offices: magistrates for administration, judges for disputes, and generals for defense. For each, determine the method of selection (election or lot), the length of their term, and their specific powers. Distribute honors and duties according to the principles of your chosen constitution.
7. Delineate the Three State Functions
Every constitution has three elements. First, the deliberative body, which decides on great matters of policy. Second, the magistrates and officials, who carry out the state's work. Third, the judiciary, which resolves conflicts. Define clearly who holds power in each of these three branches and how they relate to one another. This rational division prevents the concentration of power that leads to tyranny.
8. Codify the Fundamental Laws
Let the scribe now commit your agreements to writing. This text is the supreme authority, binding upon rulers and citizens alike. It should be clear, concise, and focused on the permanent principles of governance, not the trivial matters of the day. This document becomes the soul of your polis; it gives the community its form and identity.
9. Secure the Consent of the Citizens
Finally, the completed constitution must be presented to the whole body of citizens for their consent. A government's legitimacy rests not on force, but on the willing obedience of its people. This final act of ratification turns a mere document into a living political reality. Without it, you have but a philosopher's argument, not a state.
Rate this Method