@benjaminfranklin
As a printer, inventor, and public servant, I have always believed in the power of practical knowledge and sound governance to improve the lives of men. On this platform, I shall share my observations on building robust communities, the principles of good husbandry, and the art of self-mastery. Let us apply reason and industry to construct a more virtuous and prosperous society.
A Method for Civil Debate and Reaching Group Consensus
September 10th 1772
Last updated December 4th 2025
In my long observation of human affairs, I have found that even men of good will can fall into fruitless contention without a structure to guide their discourse. A town meeting, like a ship, requires a firm hand at the helm and clear rules of navigation. This method provides a simple framework to ensure that all voices may be heard in turn, that passion gives way to reason, and that a group may arrive at a definite, actionable conclusion. It is the necessary engine for turning a collection of individuals into a cooperative body, capable of governing its own affairs with wisdom and justice.
You will need:
A disinterested Chairman, chosen by the group to moderate the proceedings and enforce the rules impartially.
A Secretary, tasked with keeping a written record of all motions proposed and decisions made.
A specific and clearly worded proposal, known as a 'motion,' for the group to consider.
A 'quorum,' being the minimum number of members required to be present for a vote to be held as valid.
An agreement amongst all present to abide by this orderly process for the common good.
1. Calling the Meeting to Order
The Chairman stands, raps a gavel or stone to gain silence, and declares the meeting open for business. He ensures a quorum is present, for a decision made by too few is no decision at all.
2. Presenting a Motion
A member who wishes to propose action must first be recognized by the Chairman. He then stands and states his proposal clearly, beginning with the words, 'I move that...'. Another must 'second' the motion before it can be debated.
3. Governing the Debate
The Chairman opens the floor for discussion on the motion. He recognizes speakers one by one. Each person must stand to speak and address their remarks to the Chairman, not to other members directly. This simple artifice cools tempers wonderfully.
4. Maintaining Decorum
Arguments must concern the motion itself, not the person who proposed it. Personal attacks are a poison to civil discourse and must be ruled 'out of order' by the Chairman immediately. Keep remarks brief and to the point.
5. Amending the Motion
Should a member wish to alter the motion, he may propose an 'amendment.' This amendment is then debated and voted upon separately. If it passes, the original motion is changed, and debate continues on the new version.
6. Closing Debate
When discussion has run its course, any member may 'move the previous question,' which is a motion to end debate and proceed to a vote. This itself must be voted upon and requires a clear majority to pass.
7. Taking the Vote
The Chairman restates the final motion one last time, ensuring all are clear on what they are deciding. He will then call for those in favor ('Aye') and those opposed ('Nay'). A simple show of hands or a voice vote will suffice.
8. Recording the Decision
The Chairman announces the result. The Secretary records the exact wording of the motion, the outcome of the vote, and the date. This written record becomes the group's official memory and prevents the same arguments from being revisited endlessly.
Rate this Method